Deloitte Penalized Rs 2 Crore for Mistakes in Zee Audit: A Look at Other Similar Cases

310

The National Financial Reporting Authority (NFRA) has penalized Deloitte Haskins & Sells LLP with a hefty Rs 2-crore fine due to significant audit lapses in Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd (ZEEL) during the fiscal years 2018-19 and 2019-20. Additionally, two Chartered Accountants (CAs), A.B. Jani and Rakesh Sharma, involved in the audit process, were fined and barred from audit work for five and three years, respectively. The lapses revolve around unreported irregularities, including misrepresentation of a Rs 200 crore fixed deposit used as a loan guarantee without board approval.

Understanding Deloitte Haskins & Sells LLP

1. Operational and Revenue Model

Deloitte Haskins & Sells LLP is one of the “Big Four” accounting firms, operating globally. It offers services in auditing, consulting, financial advisory, tax, and risk management. The firm’s revenue is primarily generated from client fees for professional services, ranging from statutory audits to corporate strategy consultations.

2. Background and Services

Deloitte, established in 1845, has a long history of excellence in financial reporting and advisory. The firm operates across industries, including media, technology, and finance. Deloitte’s Indian branch, part of Deloitte Asia-Pacific, has been pivotal in servicing large Indian corporations with auditing and advisory needs.

The Case of Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd

1. Background of Zee Entertainment

ZEEL, a flagship company of the Essel Group, is a leading player in India’s media and entertainment sector. Established in 1992, ZEEL operates numerous television channels and digital platforms, contributing significantly to India’s cultural and entertainment ecosystem.

2. The Lapses Identified

The NFRA’s findings point to severe negligence by Deloitte during its audits of ZEEL for FY 2018-19 and 2019-20. Specific lapses include:

• Misrepresentation of Fixed Deposits: ZEEL’s chairman committed a Rs 200 crore fixed deposit as a guarantee for loans to Essel Group entities without board or shareholder approval.
• Auditor Negligence: Deloitte failed to detect and report these irregularities, violating basic auditing principles of due diligence and skepticism.

3. Penalties Imposed

• Deloitte Haskins & Sells LLP: Fined Rs 2 crore.
• A.B. Jani: Engagement Partner (EP) fined Rs 10 lakh and barred for five years.
• Rakesh Sharma: Engagement Quality Control Review (EQCR) Partner fined Rs 5 lakh and barred for three years.

Deloitte’s History of Audit Lapses

This is not the first instance of Deloitte facing regulatory scrutiny. Below are notable past cases:

1. Exam Cheating Scandal

• Deloitte Indonesia and Philippines fined $2 million collectively for exam-related misconduct from 2017 to 2019.

2. Huarong Asset Management Case

• China imposed a $31 million fine and suspended Deloitte’s Beijing operations for failing to assess Huarong’s asset quality.

3. SIG Audit Failures

• The UK’s Financial Reporting Council (FRC) fined Deloitte £1.14 million for its substandard audit of SIG.

4. Autonomy Audit Failures

• Deloitte faced a record £15 million fine in the UK for failings in audits of the software company Autonomy.

NFRA’s Role in Upholding Audit Integrity

The NFRA’s mandate is to ensure transparency, accuracy, and integrity in financial reporting. By imposing stringent penalties, it underscores its zero-tolerance policy towards professional misconduct in auditing.

Learning for Startups and Entrepreneurs

1. Importance of Audit Compliance: Startups should ensure rigorous compliance with audit and financial reporting standards to avoid regulatory issues.
2. Corporate Governance: Transparent decision-making processes and board approvals for critical transactions are non-negotiable.
3. Auditor Selection: Vet auditors for their professional history and adherence to ethical standards.
4. Regulatory Awareness: Stay informed about laws and regulations to ensure compliance and avoid penalties.

About The Startups News

When it comes to providing insights on audit integrity and regulatory compliance, The Startups News is your go-to platform for breaking news, industry trends, and actionable learnings. We empower entrepreneurs with real-time updates and data-driven insights to build resilient businesses. From startup compliance to financial strategy, we’ve got you covered.